• Home
  • Reviews
    • Flight Reviews
    • Hotel Reviews
    • Lounge Reviews
    • Trip Reports
  • About
    • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Award Expert
Live and Let's Fly
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • Flight Reviews
    • Hotel Reviews
    • Lounge Reviews
    • Trip Reports
  • About
    • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Award Expert
Home » News » Unpopular: Variably-Priced Awards Are Better For Most
Award BookingsAward TravelNews

Unpopular: Variably-Priced Awards Are Better For Most

Kyle Stewart Posted onSeptember 8, 2019September 14, 2021 13 Comments

By November of 2019, the three largest airlines in the world (American, Delta and United) will all have variably-priced award flights in one form or another. Frequent flyers lament them, but for most travellers, it’s good news.


If you are considering booking travel or signing up for a new credit card please click here. Both support LiveAndLetsFly.com.


If you haven’t followed us on Facebook or Instagram, add us today.

Countering My Own Analysis, Kind Of

Five months ago, I wrote that variably-priced (or dynamically-priced) award charts hurt loyal but infrequent travellers. This post seems to counter my previous analysis but there are two reasons why it’s not a total u-turn. Award charts help loyal but infrequent travellers (ex. passengers that always fly United but only fly twice annually) plan for award trips. That’s still true. Second, infrequent flyers typically have lower account balances thus less likely to be able to absorb higher prices when awards increase without notice. That’s also still true.

Now for a complete u-turn.

Variably-Priced Awards vs. Fixed Price Award Chart

Traditionally, airline frequent flyer programs established an award chart with fixed rates for routes usually based on distance or regions (North America to Europe, Intra-European flights.) Fixed price awards allow consumers to plan better but are susceptible to limited availability.

Variably-priced awards aren’t directly tied to revenue costs for a flight rather to availability. Those two aren’t the same but often act similarly. Unlike awards with Southwest and JetBlue which are directly tied to the cash cost of a seat, variably-priced awards still seem to hold onto price buckets. For example, Delta might price awards to Europe on emptier flights at 20,000 points roundtrip, whereas Southwest may charge 5,637 points for a one-way to Florida from the Northeast.

Southwest cash prices
Southwest cash prices
Southwest variably-priced awards
Southwest variably-priced awards

Who Benefits From Variably-Priced Awards?

Those who typically fly coach awards and have smaller balances benefit the most. In the past, there was a term “orphaned miles” which described miles that didn’t fit into a mileage balance you were collecting and would be left without a home. For example, assume you took a random flight on Alaska Airlines but otherwise haven’t built a balance large enough to redeem for a one-way award flight, that balance of miles would be orphaned.

With smaller balances, airlines have made those airlines more useful than in the past. An underlying worry to my previous post was that prices would become untenable for many travellers who aren’t on the road accruing hundreds of thousands every year. In a credit to Delta, they have offered a lot of value

Why Frequent Flyers Hate Them

Frequent Flyers have larger balances and generally, know the system better. They routinely find outsized value for premium cabin seats on long haul flights. An award to Cape Town from New York City can cost as little as 102,000 miles roundtrip with ANA. The same route in cash I priced randomly for $3,680-$5,344.

Airplanes have fewer business and first class seats, opportunities for outsized value is diminished with variably-priced awards.

Cheapest fixed award chart NYC-CPT
Cheapest fixed award chart NYC-CPT
Business Class NYC-CPT Cash Price
Business Class NYC-CPT Cash Price

Why Do Variably-Priced Awards Benefit Most Travellers?

The vast majority of awards that are redeemed are coach awards. Every year the Wall Street Journal highlights the best programs with which to redeem miles. Every year, Southwest wins. Why? Because as long as the flight is not completely sold out, they offer a seat in coach (though there is no saver level and they only offer coach so it’s flawed.)

American Airlines (who variably prices awards by but within an award chart) and other carriers report their redemption levels and how many of those seats were offered at saver level. American has made more available at saver level for coach awards, but not business class long haul seats. However, as those are less often redeemed, it’s absolutely true that more travellers benefit from both an increase in seats available and the lower available prices of those seats.

Conclusion

Delta has offered flights at 18,000-30,000 miles to Europe roundtrip during their weekly award sales with suprising consistency. Maybe that’s down to Delta being on their best behavior. But American, who I have otherwise lambasted for their award behavior has made good on offering discount prices for awards on short routes and have improved availability. As much as I personally fail to benefit from dynamically-priced coach awards, most travellers do and that’s good news for flyers.

What do you think? Are variably-priced awards generally better for most consumers? Are they a slippery slope toward award costs increases? Would you move to an airline that has fixed award charts? 

Get Daily Updates

Join our mailing list for a daily summary of posts! We never sell your info.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Previous Article Naughty: Spirit Pushed Credit, Not Refund, For Cancelled Flights
Next Article Busted AA Mechanic Was Fired From Alaska Airlines For Fraud And Incompetence

About Author

Kyle Stewart

Kyle is a freelance travel writer with contributions to Time, the Washington Post, MSNBC, Yahoo!, Reuters, Huffington Post, MapHappy, Live And Lets Fly and many other media outlets. He is also co-founder of Scottandthomas.com, a travel agency that delivers "Travel Personalized." He focuses on using miles and points to provide a premium experience for his wife and daughter. Email: sherpa@thetripsherpa.com

Follow us on FacebookFollow us on Twitter

Related Posts

  • PLAY Airlines Iceland

    Southwest’s (Possible) European Expansion Another Misstep

    June 22, 2025
  • American Airlines Q1 2025

    American Airlines Makes Good On Loyalty Points Data Snafu

    June 8, 2025
  • JetBlue Madrid

    United-JetBlue Tie Up Leaves American Airlines Bloodied

    June 1, 2025

13 Comments

  1. Arthur Reply
    September 8, 2019 at 3:23 pm

    What this change, and other downgrades to status while making status harder to get, is saying is that they do not think rewarding loyalty to the brand is as important as it used to be. When you are selling out flights regardless, that may be economically rational. If that changes and competition gets tougher, though, a lack of loyalty will make recovery harder. Especially if you have a bad brand.

    • Kyle Stewart Reply
      September 8, 2019 at 11:21 pm

      I agree that when the next recession hits, and it will, they will be in serious trouble. The Pareto principle (80% of your business comes from 20% of your customers) will tilt attention back to those elites that they’ve alienated.

      • Stuart Reply
        September 9, 2019 at 7:45 pm

        When the recession hits the legacy carriers will come running to their once loyal customers promising fields of daisies to run naked through and a plethora of promotions to beg forgiveness. “Oh, we are sorry!! Here’s a nice saver award level for out very beloved customers to thank you for the $1k tickets you pay to Des Moines.” And when the recession is over they will go back to not giving a flying F%!ck and give their free seats to Non-Rev employees before ever selling them at a reasonable mileage to their most “loyal” customers. Not gonna fool me this time around. I’d rather fly Southwest. At least they are honest with their crap.

  2. Stuart Reply
    September 8, 2019 at 4:37 pm

    Check Anywhere in the U.S. to Brazil between now and February in Business or First on AA and tell me if dynamic pricing is working for the passengers who spend the most with American. Further, check with expert flyer on the number of seats available (especially in Business and First).

    Even at the last minute (which used to be the saving grace of saver levels for those of us who would play the waiting game) business and first is virtually empty on many flights and they are forcing you into “dynamic” pricing to 150K and more. American is failing themselves AND their best customers. They prefer to upgrade non-revs for nothing rather than offer last minute saver awards to their Exec Plats in a bait to make them spend more miles. Screw it, moving to United where at least they tend to offer more last minute opportunities.

    • Kyle Stewart Reply
      September 8, 2019 at 11:30 pm

      It’s certainly not working for the customers that spend the most. I linked in the post that American Airlines Awards Abide Abysmally and I find that in my own experience too. I moved to United a few years ago but haven’t built enough miles yet to see if the award space is better, but I had enough of American’s flights showing 150k one-way or 110k one-way to Europe with $400 in surcharges on BA while the cabins are clearly empty.

  3. 121Pilot Reply
    September 8, 2019 at 6:21 pm

    In the end it comes down to what you want to do with your miles. If your happy to use them to grab tickets in Coach over paying cash then these are a great deal for you.

    But if your goal is aspirational travel then dynamically prices awards are a major setback. Because the average person who is earning miles on personal spend is going to struggle to accumulate enough miles for those redemptions. Especially when the price is a moving target.

    • Stuart Reply
      September 8, 2019 at 7:29 pm

      Aspirational travel? For years as an Exec Plat I did just fine booking flights to Brazil to my second home a day or two prior to travel at saver levels. Seats were VERY often released at Saver levels a few days before. In the past 8-12 months they have completely vanished.

      What is frustrating is that half the cabins in AA in business and, especially First, are filled with non-revs to Brazil because they go unsold. Fly any flight to GRU and you are surrounded by AA employees in premium cabins, especially in First.

      Aspirational? Aspirational is Singapore First in the new suites. A basic last minute First at a saver level on AA to Brazil when the cabin is empty is not being greedy. American is baiting and forcing more miles off people with flights that are half full the day before. If they want to do that with non butt in seat flyers, ok. But for Exec Plats who pay $1000 to fly to Des Moines during the week it’s outrageous.

      This is why I will switch to United soon as they are much better with releasing premium cabins a few days out. Well, until they follow suit….as I am sure they will eventually. Then I am pretty much screwed as Alaska on the east coast is not a viable option for me. Which will probably mean I will just fly Southwest domestically and pay for Business on quality Intl carriers…and screw the legacy U.S. airlines

      What we need is more competition.

    • Kyle Stewart Reply
      September 8, 2019 at 11:34 pm

      @121 – We agree. I have a lot of friends who signed up for a single card with a single bonus, spent it, and then continued to spend on that card and fly that airline but never accumulate enough for another trip. One in particular signed up for a Delta card (not my recommendation) and doesn’t have enough miles for a roundtrip from Omaha to Pittsburgh, but does have enough to go roundtrip from Minneapolis to Paris. It doesn’t deliver the exact value they want, but for a six-hour drive to the twin cities they can see the city of lights, that’s hard to argue with.

      I think I mentioned this in the post, but in case I didn’t, it’s really been down to Delta delivering valuable options instead of just saying they were making “enhancements” they actually kept their part of the bargain.

  4. Evan Reply
    September 8, 2019 at 7:58 pm

    To state the obvious: this is true for MOST TRAVELERS. It’s almost certainly NOT true for MOST BOARDINGAREA VISITORS.

    • Kyle Stewart Reply
      September 8, 2019 at 10:52 pm

      You’d be surprised. Besides, I find value in AMEX-Delta transfers if it means I can send friends who don’t care about the class of service to Europe for 36,000 points roundtrip combined.

  5. Dick Bupkiss Reply
    September 8, 2019 at 10:08 pm

    To summarize your argument:

    Variable award pricing is good for idiots, those who don’t plan ahead, and the lazy.

    For those who know what they’re doing, want to (or need to) actually plan ahead, and/or are willing to put in a little effort, variable award pricing is a disaster.

    There’s your article, without all the fluff.

    You’re welcome.

    • Kyle Stewart Reply
      September 8, 2019 at 10:51 pm

      @Dick Bupkiss – Thanks for the summary.

  6. JNBflyer Reply
    September 9, 2019 at 12:16 am

    Cape Town * not Capetown

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Search

Hot Deals for July

Note: Please see my Advertiser Disclosure

Capital One Venture X Business Card
Earn 150,000 Miles Sign Up Bonus
Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card
Earn 100,000 Points
Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card
Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card
Earn 75,000 Miles!
Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card
Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card
Earn 75,000 Miles
Chase Ink Business Unlimited® Credit Card
Earn $750 Cash Back
The Business Platinum Card® from American Express
The Business Platinum Card® from American Express
Earn 120,000 Membership Reward® Points

Recent Posts

  • a plate of food on a table
    Succulent Steak On A Plane: LX17 From JFK-ZRH In First Class July 15, 2025
  • a plane parked at an airport
    Newark Airport Meltdown: Trapped Passengers Wait 5+ Hours For Gate July 15, 2025
  • a group of people sitting at tables in a restaurant
    Our Brunch And Bimble In Paris July 15, 2025
  • Eiffel Tower
    Eiffel Tower: A Tourist Trap You Must Climb At Least Once July 14, 2025

Categories

Popular Posts

  • a blue passport on a black surface
    All The Patriotic Quotes In Your U.S. Passport July 4, 2025
  • a lobby with a marble counter and a wood ceiling
    Review: Korean Air KAL Business Lounge Los Angeles (LAX) July 1, 2025
  • a row of seats in an airplane
    If You Abuse Company Travel Policy, Expect To Be Fired! June 16, 2025
  • United PlusPoints Uses
    United Airlines Expands Redemption Options For PlusPoints (Full List) June 19, 2025

Archives

July 2025
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
« Jun    

As seen on:

facebook twitter instagram rss
Privacy Policy © Live and Let's Fly All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Live and Let's Fly with appropriate and specific directions to the original content.