• Home
  • Reviews
    • Flight Reviews
    • Hotel Reviews
    • Lounge Reviews
    • Trip Reports
  • About
    • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Award Expert
Live and Let's Fly
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • Flight Reviews
    • Hotel Reviews
    • Lounge Reviews
    • Trip Reports
  • About
    • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Award Expert
Home » Law In Travel » U.S. Supreme Court Debates First Class Vs. Economy Class
Law In Travel

U.S. Supreme Court Debates First Class Vs. Economy Class

Matthew Klint Posted onApril 30, 2020November 14, 2023 9 Comments

a statue of a woman sitting on a pillar

A narrow majority on the U.S. Supreme Court indicated a preference for “first class” information over “economy class” information in a recent ruling, using a metaphor that strikes close to home.

No, this is not really a travel-related post. Those who are aware of my legal background may know that I am a close watcher of the Supreme Court and follow its entire docket closely. Every article from Supreme Court reporters like Adam Liptak of the New York Times or David Savage of the Los Angeles Times is required reading for me and I closely follow the SCOTUSblog.

Well, it’s not often that I get to address the Supreme Court on Live and Let’s Fly, but I’ll do so here…on a copyright case.

Earlier this week, the Supreme Court narrowly held in Georgia v Public.Resource.Org that under the government edicts doctrine, the annotations beneath the statutory provisions in the Official Code of Georgia Annotated are ineligible for copyright protection.

Uh, what…?

Put simply, states cannot copyright commentary on laws, even if prepared at a high cost, if they commission the work. To put that in context, Georgia made statutory texts and caselaw available for free, but if you wanted access to commentary on the these measures, including whether the law or court holding was still valid, you had to pay services like LexisNexis  or travel to a legal library to consult a physical book. The majority, split along unusual ideological lines, held that “whatever work that judge or legislator produces in the course of his judicial or legislative duties is not copyrightable.” More analysis here on the case, if you are interested.

A metaphor in Chief Justice Robert’s majority opinion caught my attention:

“…Imagine a Georgia citizen in- terested in learning his legal rights and duties. If he reads the economy-class version of the Georgia Code available online, he will see laws requiring political candidates to pay hefty qualification fees (with no indigency exception), criminalizing broad categories of consensual sexual conduct, and exempting certain key evidence in criminal trials from standard evidentiary limitations—with no hint that important aspects of those laws have been held unconstitutional by the Georgia Supreme Court….

“Meanwhile, first-class readers with access to the annotations will be assured that these laws are, in crucial respects, unenforceable relics that the legislature has not bothered to narrow or repeal…”

(bolding mine)

I like the metaphor and on a personal note, applaud the decision because it encourages transparency and access to information.

CONCLUSION

Perhaps metaphors about first class versus economy class are better than the SCOTUS actually delving into frequent flyer issues. But it did make the decision all the more relatable…


> Read More: A Meaningless Supreme Court Decision on Frequent Flyer Miles

Get Daily Updates

Join our mailing list for a daily summary of posts! We never sell your info.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Previous Article Delta’s Ludicrous Contradiction On Air Travel Safety
Next Article American, Delta, United Make Masks Mandatory For All Passengers

About Author

Matthew Klint

Matthew is an avid traveler who calls Los Angeles home. Each year he travels more than 200,000 miles by air and has visited more than 135 countries. Working both in the aviation industry and as a travel consultant, Matthew has been featured in major media outlets around the world and uses his Live and Let's Fly blog to share the latest news in the airline industry, commentary on frequent flyer programs, and detailed reports of his worldwide travel.

Related Posts

  • a jet plane on a runway

    JetBlue Pilot Wins Landmark Compensation Case Against His Airline

    August 13, 2020
  • Hilton voyeur Lawsuit

    Why Is This Attractive Couple Suing Hilton?

    May 26, 2020
  • a white airplane flying over water

    Cathay Pacific Faces Grave Threat As Massive Protests Loom In Hong Kong

    May 25, 2020

9 Comments

  1. Adil Reply
    April 30, 2020 at 3:25 pm

    This is a first class blog!

  2. derek Reply
    April 30, 2020 at 5:34 pm

    Further explanation, please!

    ROBERTS, SOTOMAYOR, KAGAN, GORSUCH, and KAVANAUGH
    versus
    THOMAS, ALITO, BREYER
    GINSBURG

    So conservatives and liberal want equal access to annotated version of the law but 2 conservatives and 2 liberals are elitist and only want paying snobs to have access to all of the annotations????

  3. Lucas Reply
    April 30, 2020 at 6:36 pm

    In most of Continental Europe, everything produced by the government (and public authorities more generally) is public domain by definition, and there are also, in many places, open-government initiatives which collate this data in useful ways.

    To me this parallel with Economy/First-class information only underscores how inappropriate a profit-based approach is when talking about basic government functions (in this case the law).

    And thank you for this judicial note from a fellow lawyer!

  4. ps241 Reply
    April 30, 2020 at 6:44 pm

    Can a result that has Ginsburg and Breyer dissenting along with Thomas and Alito really be described as a decision “split along unusual ideological lines”?

    • Matthew Reply
      April 30, 2020 at 7:20 pm

      Unusual? Yes.

  5. PM1 Reply
    April 30, 2020 at 8:02 pm

    Thanks for covering this Matthew! I remember my time in law school in Georgia when LexisNexis and Westlaw were free. It was so easy to look up the comments on the OCGA and case law. The harsh reality about the cost hit after the bar exam. 🙂

  6. Brian G. Reply
    April 30, 2020 at 8:33 pm

    Any chance for a post about what Northwest v Ginsberg means in 2020? Given that SCOTUS’s decision had a note about non-airline point earning.

    • Matthew Reply
      April 30, 2020 at 8:41 pm

      Let me think about it – you’re right that the landscape is different in 2020.

  7. Andy K Reply
    May 1, 2020 at 12:27 am

    Cool story. I would also like more analysis of how the Court split up in the end…

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Search

Hot Deals for May

Note: Please see my Advertiser Disclosure

Capital One Venture X Business Card
Earn 150,000 Miles Sign Up Bonus
Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card
Earn 100,000 Points
Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card
Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card
Earn 75,000 Miles!
Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card
Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card
Earn 75,000 Miles
Chase Ink Business Unlimited® Credit Card
Earn $750 Cash Back
The Business Platinum Card® from American Express
The Business Platinum Card® from American Express
Earn 120,000 Membership Reward® Points

Recent Posts

  • Turkey Fine Passengers Unbuckle
    Impatient Flyers, Beware: Turkey Will Fine You For Standing Up Too Soon May 28, 2025
  • Korean Air First Class Lounge ICN Review
    Review: Korean Air First Class Lounge Seoul (ICN) May 28, 2025
  • a group of people in blue uniforms
    United Airlines’ Uniforms Get A Facelift—And A Political Filter May 28, 2025
  • Dog Diversion Delta
    Delta Flight Diverts To Care For Sick Dog. Justified? May 28, 2025

Categories

Popular Posts

  • United Airlines Polaris Lounge Chicago Review
    Review: United Polaris Lounge Chicago (ORD) May 1, 2025
  • United Airlines Refresh Polaris Lounge Chicago
    First Look: United Airlines Reopens Renovated Polaris Lounge In Chicago (ORD) April 29, 2025
  • a hand holding a blue card
    Chase Sapphire Preferred 100K Bonus Offer Ending Soon May 2, 2025
  • Aegean Airlines Feast
    A Feast Fit For A King On Aegean Airlines May 23, 2025

Archives

May 2025
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  
« Apr    

As seen on:

facebook twitter instagram rss
Privacy Policy © Live and Let's Fly All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Live and Let's Fly with appropriate and specific directions to the original content.