UPDATE: A grand jury will not pursue attempted murder charges against 44-year-old Alaska Airlines captain Joseph David Emerson, but instead voted to indict the pilot on 84 other criminal charges.
Grand Jury Decides Alaska Airlines Pilot Won’t Face Attempted Murder Charges
Instead of facing attempted murder charges, Emerson will face one felony charge of endangering an aircraft and 83 misdemeanor counts of reckless endangerment.
Emerson claims he never intended to hurt anyone.
> Read More: Alaska Airlines Pilot Accused Of Attempted Murder Shares His Side Of The Story
Attorneys for Emerson expressed dismay over the charges the grand jury chose to pursue, but will petition to have him released later this week and vow to fight all charges in a jury trial.
“Captain Emerson had no criminal intent, and we look forward to being able to present a fulsome defense at trial and bring forth all the facts and circumstances to a jury. Captain Emerson’s defense team is crafting a release plan and expect that he will finally return home to his family by the end of this week.”
No trial date has yet been set, though Emerson will be arraigned on Thursday, December 7, 2023. He is currently being held in Portland, Oregon at the Multnomah County Detention Center.
The original story, which appeared on October 24, 2023, is below.
An off-duty Alaska Airlines pilot traveling in a cockpit jump seat has been charged with attempted murder and reckless endangerment after attempting to turn off aircraft engines in-flight.
Alaska Airlines Pilot Charged With Attempted Murder After Trying to Disable Engines On Horizon Air Flight
44-year-old Alaska Airlines captain Joseph David Emerson assumed a jump seat position in the cockpit of a Horizon Air Embraer E-175 regional jet on Sunday, set to operate as Alaska 2059 from Paine Field in Everett, Washington (PAE) to San Francisco (SFO). Off-duty pilots are permitted to ride jumpseat in the flight deck with the approval of the flight’s captain.
Just after takeoff, Emerson allegedly tried “to disable the aircraft engines while at cruise altitude by deploying the engine fire suppressions system.” (per an internal American Airlines memo, shared by JonNYC and flagged by View From The Wing).
His action was overridden by the pilot and first officer, who were able to subdue him and remove him from the cockpit. The flight diverted to Portland, Oregon (PDX) where it was met by law enforcement officials. Emerson was purportedly cooperative after being ejected from the flight deck and not motive has been revealed for his alleged action.
Air Traffic Control audio reveals the captain onboard AS2059 reported the incident in this way:
“We’ve got the guy that tried to shut the engines down out of the cockpit. It doesn’t sound like he’s got any issue in the back right now. I think he’s subdued. Other than that we want law enforcement as soon as we get on the ground and parked.”
No injuries were reported onboard, with Alaska Airlines issuing a vague statement about hte incident:
“Alaska Airlines Flight 2059 operated by Horizon Air from Everett, WA (PAE) to San Francisco, CA (SFO) reported a credible security threat related to an authorized occupant in the flight deck jump seat. The crew secured the aircraft without incident.
“Following appropriate FAA procedures and guidance from air traffic control, the flight safely diverted to Portland International Airport. The event is being investigated by law enforcement authorities.
“All passengers on board were able to travel on a later flight. We are grateful for the professional handling of the situation by the Horizon flight crew and appreciate our guests’ calm and patience throughout this event.”
The FBI has also confirmed it arrested Emerson and is investigating the incident:
“One man is under arrest on state charges in Oregon, booked by the Port of Portland Police Department, after an incident in the air on Horizon Air flight 2059 from Everett, WA to San Francisco, CA. The airplane’s pilot was able to safely land the plane at Portland International Airport around 6:25 pm on Sunday, October 22. No injuries were reported. The FBI is investigating and can assure the traveling public there is no continuing threat related to this incident.”
Emerson now faces 167 criminal counts, including 83 counts of attempted murder, 83 counts of reckless endangerment, and one count of endangering an aircraft.
What Could Have Prompted This Incident?
what prompted such a brazen incident is indeed the key question going forward, but until we have more definitive news from the FAA or Alaska Airlines, I do not think it profits us to speculate.
However, if someone knows Emerson, please do chime in with a comment below.
CONCLUSION
The shock of this incident underscores how rare events like these are and how safe the airline system is. Frankly, I am surprised there are not more incidents like this. But I am elated that the pilots so quickly corrected the attempted murder and subdued Emerson, but we really do have to wonder what possibly could have gone through his mind to put so many people at risk.
“I do not think it profits us to speculate”
I’m sure that won’t stop people from doing it anyway…
In all the reporting on this, I have yet to hear if he was in a pilot’s uniform. That would be incredibly scary for passengers to see that. It’s bad enough if he’s Joe Anybody coming out of the cockpit in these circumstances, but if he were in a pilot’s uniform too, that would be a whole new level of fear.
Very sad situation. At 44 years old, he was in the. middle of his career. No chance of sitting behind the controls of a passenger jet from this point forward, even if found not guilty. Don’t forget the impact on spouse and children.
I get the impression he was crying out for help. I’ve met one or two professionals (not pilots) who were too proud to ask for assistance. However, their profession had an image that shunned any sign of weakness.
Not a happy place.
Had this individual been successful in bringing that aircraft down, we’d all be denouncing him as a ‘madman’ and ‘mass murderer’ and howling for blood. However, the ‘all’s well that ends well’ fallacy is now evident here.
Let’s stop making excuses for reckless stupidity and blaming a system instead of the individual’s poor choice. It’s possible that he’s going through some tough stuff and didn’t feel enabled to ask for help. Yet, many others are out there who are able to manage it, or they ask for help. His actions diminish the efforts of those who do.
Permanent loss of flying privileges is a given. At a minimum, this person needs some serious prison time to reflect on the consequences of his careless actions.
Finally some reason from a grand jury. On the face of it, there is no criminal intent. A man sleep deprived for 48 hours, who had a bad reaction to a substance he wasn’t familiar with, and likely suffering from ptsd from the death of his friend isn’t making calculated and intentional choices. The fact that he left the cockpit after being told to do so and walked to the back of the aircraft and told a flight attendant he needed to be restrained is more evidence he didn’t intend to murder or harm anyone.
Thankfully the grand jury got it right and weren’t rubber stamps for the police state and government. Jurors should always assume the police and government are being evil, unreasonable, and persecuting someone unless proven otherwise. Too often they are rubber stamps for the government despite them saying they don’t trust the government if you ask them if they trust the government. Cops, prosecutors, and judges are the government.
His attorney is correct that all charges should be dismissed. There was no criminal intent. This is a mental health issue. He needed to be sent for a mental health evaluation and received treatment. We had millions of violent criminals roaming the streets burning down businesses, looting, and terrorizing communities and millions of violent and low culture illegals pouring in but the government goes after a man with a mental health issue. Disgusting. The leftists constantly discuss mental health to excuse the violence perpetrated by certain groups but when it comes to a White pilot suddenly mental illness doesn’t exist.