While the Alila Marea Beach Resort Encinitas represents a great value for Hyatt loyalists and offers many attractive amenities, my stay at this beachside hotel will likely be my one and only.
Alila Marea Beach Resort Encinitas Review
I was very excited to try this hotel, which opened in 2021 and is part of a hotel brand that also includes the superb Alila Ventana Big Sur in California, a hotel my wife Heidi and I both love. Heidi gave me the perfect excuse to book a night here: she had an appointment in Encinitas just a couple miles down the road from the hotel. We debated whether to make it a date night or bring the kids along, but decided to bring the kids because of the pool and beach location.
This hotel is not cheap…a base room was running $650 for our Friday night stay. I could have used a confirmed suite upgrade to confirm us into a suite, as my two children would be coming along, but decided to roll my dice with a complimentary elite upgrade since we were only staying for one night.
This hotel is currently a Category 6 property in the World of Hyatt program, meaning a free night ranges from 21,000 (off-peak) to 29,000 (peak) points per night. On March 22, 2022, it will move to a Category 7, topping out at 35,000 points per night. Our stay, in February 2022, was during a standard period, which cost 25,000 points per night. We felt that was a great value, considering it included $52 valet parking (with complimentary electric charging).
As a Hyatt Globalist, my $50 resort fee was also waived and I received free breakfast for my entire family.
We left Los Angeles after my son Augustine finished kindergarten for the day and arrived around 4:00pm. The hotel is off of I-5, about a mile down the road at the intersection of La Costa Avenue and US-101. The hotel is not secluded down a long driveway, but directly off of the street.
A valet took my car and also gave me a claim ticket for our bags in the trunk.
Inside, I was warmly greeted by a host named Kevin, who welcomed me to the property and quickly checked me in. He also informed me I had been upgraded to a king bed studio suite with a coastline View and a fire pit, which was going for $852/night.
The lobby is small, with a few chairs and the check-in desk, where I was invited to sit down to check-in. Our room, 135, was located on the first level (one floor up from lobby) and down a long hallway. We noticed the gym was located directly across from our room. More on that in a bit…
Even though we did not have a suite, the room was large, with a very comfortable bed in the center, a couch in front of the bed, another couch on the side of the bed, and a round table with chairs in the corner.
The bathroom was huge, with a full-size bathtub, walk-in shower big enough for a party, and even a separate “powder” area.
Toiletries were from VOTARY and I really liked the rosemary and chia scent (plus the unique toothpaste-like tubes).
Other toiletries like mouthwash and dental kits were proactively provided:
But perhaps the highlight of the room was the lovely terrace outside, which included a U-shaped couch (also big enough for a party) and a fire pit.
While we could see the ocean from the room, we could also look over into our neighbors patio and our primary view was of the parking lot below.
Of course the terrace was a bit of a danger for little Claire Marie, who loves to climb.
A couple of other things I liked. There was a nice Nespresso coffee machine that we took full advantage of and I liked the cups in the room (not the Nespresso espresso cups, but the larger coffee cups). Plus, there was a Fellow Stagg hot water kettle, the same one we have at home.
In addition to coffee, a selection of tea was available.
Water was in cans rather than bottles.
Other than two cans of hard seltzer made in nearby San Diego, the refrigerator was empty.
Two robes were in the closet and I did use one when we went swimming.
Overall, I was really pleased with the room itself and thankful for the upgrade.
Directly across from our room was the hotel’s 24/7 fitness center, which features an excellent selection of equipment from TechnoGym as well as medicine balls, kettle bells, and even a couple Peloton bikes.
My wife and I enjoyed a good workout…and so did another guest at 5:00am in the morning. We were jolted awake by a tremendous thud on the ground. Seconds later we heard it again. At first I had no idea what it was, then it dawned on me that some dude was heavy lifting in there.
That’s a real problem because I could not get back to sleep and two walls and a hallway did little to keep the noise out. It thankfully continued for only 10 minutes, but the damage was done in terms of my beauty sleep.
The pool is on the small side, also located on the first floor down the hall from my room and the fitness center, but the jacuzzi is large. Kids love pools and Augustine was so excited to jump right in. We ended up going in that night, again in the morning, and once more in the afternoon before we left.
I chucked at the picture below: you can see a house directly adjacent to the property. Can you imagine having a luxury hotel pool built on your property line?
Cabanas were available for rent while seating around a fire pit or on beach chairs could be claimed on a first-come, first-served basis.
Beyond the pool is a walkway straddling the property line along with an access point to the beach. Beaches are public in California, though I did not see many people availing themselves to the beach during my stay.
I met an Award Expert client for a meeting at the hotel bar to discuss his travel plans for the year and we enjoyed a nice chat while watching the sunset and sipping a cocktail. The bar became very busy at 5:00pm.
Here’s the full menu for the bar:
I ordered a Sunday Namaste, with gin, basil, fennel, lemon, and grapefruit but was disappointed by it: I didn’t see or taste the basil and it seemed to be garnished with dill rather than fennel.
However, the sunset was beautiful:
Dinner At Vaga
Later on, my family had dinner at Vega, which everyone I spoke to about this property raved about. The concept is interesting here: a fusion between Mexican and Indian food (at least that was my take). The chef is Claudette Zepeda, a local.
The dinner menu:
We ordered bread to start as well as some crispy roots and a mushroom & tuna tostada. Both appetizers were unremarkable and I was particularly unhappy wit the “crispy roots” which was predominantly potatoes. $16 for a small bowl of potatoes? Beautiful presentation, though.
The tostada was tasty, but once again a few bites for $20…I don’t mind splurging once in a while for a nice dinner, but it wasn’t worthwhile.
For our main courses, the kids split a smoked half chicken, Heidi ordered sea bass, and I ordered a lamb shank.
We really enjoyed the main courses and the food truly was unique. My lamb shank, for example, had pasilla curry (a strong Indian flavor) with vaquita beans (a strong Mexican flavor). One balanced the other nicely, making for a tasty juxtaposition of flavors.
Heidi’s sea bass was also very tasty and the kid’s smoked chicken had a very rich flavor with a nice sweet potato slaw (and looked more like duck than chicken). Unlike the small appetizer portions, the portions were very large and filling.
This is not a concept I would ever care to re-create at home, but I appreciated the effort and creativeness. It was a fun dinner.
Breakfast At Vaga
We returned to Vega for breakfast around 8:30am and encountered no wait for a table.
The breakfast menu:
And here’s my first major gripe about the property.
It wasn’t the lack of fresh orange juice (though there’s no excuse for that either).
I ordered a cappuccino right away and was told that the espresso machine was broken.
Hmm, okay…that happens. Knowing there was a coffee shop downstairs, I asked if they could send one up from there.
Nope. Not possible.
“I’m sorry sir, we can’t do that.”
Oh, the poor little millennial did not get his espresso. Cue the violin the size of a coffee tamper.
If you’re even a semi-frequent reader of the blog, you know how important coffee is to me. It’s one of the small joys of life that is very important to my daily life.
And when I stay in a hotel room that runs $852/night, I believe I reasonably expect a cappuccino or flat white with breakfast, especially when it is available on the premises.
I had to make do with black coffee, which wasn’t horrible…but certainly not the same.
Perhaps I was influenced by the (lack of) coffee, but the only thing I really enjoyed from breakfast was the tres leches French Toast, which was perfectly topped with whipped cream, poached pears, and a cinnamon glaze.
We also ordered the shakshuka, which is generally one of my favorite breakfast dishes, but I found tomatoes far too acidic and the herbs had a garam masala flavor that overpowered everything.
The kids ordered bacons and eggs a la carte and the fruit plate was very nice.
We racked up a $126 bill, but it was taken off completely when we checked out. We were never informed of the hotel’s specific breakfast policy, but apparently some Globalist members have been told breakfast includes one drink, one main course, and one side.
I did make it to Coffee Box, which is hip little coffee shops that sells biking attire and equipment as well.
Bless her heart, the young barista had no idea how to steam milk let alone create latte art. She was really nice and the coffee, from nearby Lofty Coffee, was very good.
So while my flat white—
lacked an artistic flare, the superb coffee made up for it.
The good coffee here made me even more disappointed the Vaga staff could not find a way to get me some espresso with breakfast.
There’s a small restaurant called The Pocket adjacent to the pool that we did not eat at. It is open daily from 12:00pm to 5:00pm for food, with drinks available until 7:00pm. Menu here.
Free bike rentals are available (to be precise, are included in the resort fee) and Heidi rented one to go to her appointment. It reminded her of Germany and she loved biking down the beautiful California coast.
Ok, last point. Another gripe. Stick with me here.
You can review the spa menu here. Massages are expensive. Look, I know I’m cheap, but even if I was fabulously wealthy I would not drop $200+ on a massage. No way.
The hotel has a nice sauna. Really nice. Every day at home I use the sauna (in my gym) and it is a critical part of my day. Here, I asked to use it and was denied.
Okay, I don’t mind paying for it. How about a guest pass?
It’s too crowded. If you want to use it, you have to book a treatment.
So space isn’t really the problem, I just have to book a treatment?
To be clear, the hotel was very polite about it. We corresponded via text and they were gracious albeit firm in their denial:
I sincerely apologize for the inconvenience; However, our spa only allows those who have a treatment booked that day to utilize the locker rooms and spa. It is also nearly completely booked today. Please advise if there is anything else we may do for you as we remain at your service. Thank you for you patience with us.
I certainly cannot fault the hotel for being impolite: they were exceedingly professional. Still, not having access to the sauna is a deal-breaker for me…I won’t return to the hotel unless I can pre-arrange access.
There’s so much to like about this hotel and I hope you found my review helpful in understanding the property and its amenities. While a sauna or espresso may mean nothing to you, those two things are critical to me, especially when I stay at a hotel that costs upwards of $600/night for a base room and is on the cusp of becoming a Category 7 hotel in the World of Hyatt program.
I hope the hotel will read this review and take my constructive criticism to heart. This isn’t a Hyatt Place or a Hampton Inn, it’s a luxury hotel. The hotel does so much right—but it can do even better.
Too long of a review. Your blog would be more relevant and popular if reviews were more succinct and helpful like onemileatatime
Uh, his review of this property was even longer…
Lol, I knew I had seen this property reviewed previously
Call me old fashioned, cheap, whatever – I feel like warm bread and butter ought to be complimentary with dinner, especially with the prices of the other menu items. Come on.
Indeed, I’m not sure why restaurants increasingly are charging for bread (beyond the fact that they can).
Very fair review, Matthew and you are spot on. In fact, a bit generous in one area, the rooms. I assure you that if you had been there during a busy beach period you would have despised the fire pit rooms on the ground floor. Literally an endless flow of people will be walking down that pathway to the beach with full sight into your room and outdoor area from two feet away. There is just no privacy at all. So, while the fire pit is nice, the upper level rooms above the walkway do add more privacy. The rooms are fairly identical otherwise with the fire pit area being the tradeoff. I must be one of the few that message the hotel before via my concierge and ask them NOT to upgrade me to a fire pit room.
Yes, that house, lol. I was completely perplexed by it and I can’t tell who must hate the other more, the home owner or the hotel. It’s completely bizarre and is practically a part of the hotel. I imagine there were quite a few zoning battles during the permitting to build the hotel.
My take is it’s fine for something different when on business in SD County for a night or two, or a good staycation weekend place for people in LA. But a destination resort this is NOT. Nothing at all what you imagine from Alila and I think they would do better rebranding to Andaz and lowering the rates as the hotel would be more in line with expectations at that point.
I believe those homes next to Alila are vacation home rentals.
There were zoning battles for this property for over 20 years! Lots of very wealthy neighbors who did not want a big hotel moving into the empty bluff next door. But Hyatt did finally win the 20 year battle.
Oh, I need to read about this. I figured this had to be a fight.
You got good value from your points and status, but this is not much of a value even paying far less in cash than the going rate. And guessing because of all the elites and need to provide freebies the cash prices for rooms and breakfast are inflated.
Too bleak and depressing design wise, no warmth or coastal energy to it.
Beaches are easy enough to access all around, so better to stay at an inland resort for less.
For ‘on the beach’ the Monarch Beach up in OC seems the better deal even if there’s a tram ride to get there.
Gym across the room? Elevator across the room? Ice machine across the room? No way!!! These are huge deal breakers for me. I immediately ask for another room even if not an upgrade.
It actually never dawned on me that would happen, but I know better for next time.
Several times I got rooms close to the areas I mentioned on my post and even before opening the door I immediately went back to the reception and asked them to change. Thanks also never get a room facing the pool. Once I made a mistake at the Grand Hyatt in Vail to get a room just 1 floor above and facing the pool. There was a convention happening at the hotel and they had a party around the pool until very late at night. People drinking, laughing and talking very loud. Never again.
I once spent a few weeks at an international hotel in Delhi. We had a nice room overlooking the lawns. Nice – except most Friday and Saturday nights there were weddings, with loud music, thumping bass rattling our windows!
Ditto on the steam/sauna. Wish more hotels in the US would provide complimentary access or at least for elite members. Perhaps a post on the best US hotels that provide access.
Just wanted to add some clarification. Any curry sauce requires a form of pepper to aid in digestion. In the case of the lamb dish,black dehydrated pasilla pepper from Mexico was used. Curry without pepper is very harsh on the GI system.
My wife and I stayed at the hotel for a wedding in October. The room was adequate, but there were tears in the bench upholstery and peeling finishing on the cabinetry. How does this exist in a newly opened hotel and why is it not recognized by the house staff and repaired. One afternoon there was a large puddle of water in the room. It appeared to originate from the shower in the adjoining room. Upon reporting this incidence there seemed to be little or no interest in investigating the cause. It is amateurish attempt at running an expensive hotel. They are trying to promote themselves as a luxury resort hotel without providing the service required.
How did nobody at the hotel/bar notice that the El Tesoro Reposado is missing the “L” and get that page of the drinks menu reprinted immediately? To me that speaks to a lack of attention to detail.
“And when I stay in a hotel room that runs $852/night, I believe I reasonably expect a cappuccino or flat white with breakfast, especially when it is available on the premises.“
I agree with you.
But maybe like the sauna, the cappuccinos were for coffee shop guests only? (I am joking)
This is the sort of thing I was commenting about on Kyle’s recent pro-Hyatt article where he claimed said that their lack if footprint is compensated by the SLH offerings, and I think it applies more widely.
Unless one is completely price-insensitive (either as a result of having more money and/or points than what they can spend or due to very generous business travel policy), staying in a top-end hotel where rates are multiple times the price of an upscale alternative is likely to lead to expectations of consistently impeccable service which will often result in disappointment if anything does go wrong with the stay. I bet you would have been far less annoyed if the espresso incident had happened in a Hilton Garden Inn or something.
“Oh, the poor little millennial did not get his espresso. Queue the violin the size of a coffee tamper.”
Yep, pretty much sums up many of your posts.
Let’s not be too hard on Matthew; after all, he isn’t the only person who confuses ‘queue’ with ‘cue’.
My thoughts exactly
I completely agree with Matthew. Things like making a proper espresso are important, this is a 5 star hotel. People seem to forget that. If you go to 5 star hotels in places other than CA, yes they can make a proper espresso drink. I don’t blame the people working there, it’s the lack of training.
Great Review Matthew.
It also serves to highlight the dichotomy for Hyatt in the points and miles game.
If your a road warrior who can achieve Globalist status there is no question that Hyatt should be your preferred brand. Just look at all the value you got on this one stay.
But if your like me and are reliant on credit cards to earn points and status then the value proposition is hugely different. Because unless I’m mistaken with Hyatt it’s basically Globalist or nothing.
My wife and I stayed 3 nights last November. Biking on points was fine but there’s no way it’s worth the cash costs, nor the upcoming points costs either. My issues:
-original room was a firepit room. We asked for and got a balcony room the next floor up, a very wise choice with tons of Saturday/Sunday morning beach for traffic immediately outside the firepits.
-by our third Globalist breakfast I was tired of the Vaga menu so ordered a la carte. Most of that was still on my bill and i had to plead my case to have it removed. They did but they didn’t want to, even with my s la carte cost being less than any breakfast entree on the menu
-the pool was tiny and packed with very inebriated guests. But then it was actually the large hot tub that was packed with the way too cold pool sitting empty
-the weekend we stayed the hotel hosted a launch party for the new Toyota electric cars and semi truck. Ok, the party was late Sunday but our stay was cluttered with event setup around the pool and the hotel clogged with industry people acting too cool for things
-oh, Sunday morning meant the very visible beach parking lot was full of activity with the new electric semi trucks beeping like crazy as the backed up. It was a photo shoot with the trucks and the new cars. So glad our beach vacation Sunday morning started at 7:30. The hotel staff said there was nothing they could do about it and they refused to even refund some small number of points
-before i forget, the coastal views are great but make sure you close the curtains at night; southbound traffic on the street outside shines their headlights directly into the rooms
-our upgraded Jr suite was not that impressive. For being open for only a matter of months it was amazingly worn. From stains on the small lounger (the only non-table chair in the room) to water damage in the bathroom to a throw rug that was rolling up on the edges it just didn’t seem very luxurious. But it really acted like it wanted to be lux…
There are many ways to get better use out of WOH points. It’s a beautiful hotel but it misses the mark on many shots, we’ll stay somewhere else in the future
No cappuccino and no sauna access are deal breakers…..LoL. What a world.
What a world indeed that a hotel can charge $850+ for a room and not offer such basic amenities.
A 5 star hotel should have their people trained to make a proper espresso yes.