• Home
  • Reviews
    • Flight Reviews
    • Hotel Reviews
    • Lounge Reviews
    • Trip Reports
  • About
    • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Award Expert
  • Advertising Disclosure
Live and Let's Fly
  • Home
  • Reviews
    • Flight Reviews
    • Hotel Reviews
    • Lounge Reviews
    • Trip Reports
  • About
    • Press
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Award Expert
  • Advertising Disclosure
Home  >  Analysis • full body scanners • News • TSA  >  D.C. Circuit Rejects Claim that TSA Full Body Scanners Violate Fourth Amendment
Analysisfull body scannersNewsTSA

D.C. Circuit Rejects Claim that TSA Full Body Scanners Violate Fourth Amendment

Matthew Klint Posted onJuly 18, 2011 2 Comments

In probing the Transportation Security Administration’s Advanced Imaging Technology program last week, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit squarely rejected the contention that the TSA’s use of AIT violates the Fourth Amendment. Distinguishing unlawful searches, the court labeled the use of AIT as a lawful “administrative search” because “the primary goal is not to determine whether any passenger has committed a crime, but rather to protect the public from a terrorist attack.” The court’s shallow analysis leaves much to be desired. To understand why, it is first necessary to examine the reason for the Fourth Amendment in the first place.

Like other portions of the Bill of Rights, the Fourth Amendment, guaranteeing protection against unreasonable government searches and seizures, came in response to particularly egregious action by the British Crown.  In the Writs of Assistance Case, British customs inspectors seeking to eradicate smuggling in colonial Boston were given blanket search warrants, called writs of assistance, that authorized them to search anywhere they believed smuggled goods might be.

A group of Boston merchants, represented by James Otis, sued, arguing that the writs were invalid. The merchants lost, but Otis’s forceful oral argument, passionately defending the notion of individual privacy, quickly spread and strengthened opposition to British rule. Speaking of the proceedings, John Adams would later declare, “Then and there the child Independence was born.”

The Writs of Assistance Case was embedded in the mind of James Madison when he drafted language for the Fourth Amendment. Most importantly, the belief that the government should not be allowed to search without some substantial justification—some reason to believe the place being searched contains the evidence being sought—represented the intent and common understanding of the Fourth Amendment. There lay the problem with writs of assistance—they authorized searches based on no more than the unsubstantiated suspicion of the inspector.

More than two hundred years later, citizens face an analogous search at airports around the nation. The court justifies AIT as part of the government’s legitimate duty to protect citizens from terrorism, but a nebulous statement about protecting the public from harm should not constitute sufficient grounds to treat American citizens as guilty until proven innocent.

The Supreme Court has held the reasonableness of an administrative search from a Fourth Amendment perspective “is determined by assessing, on the one hand, the degree to which it intrudes upon an individual’s privacy and, on the other, the degree to which it is needed for the promotion of legitimate government interests.”

With that rubric and the history of the Fourth Amendment in mind, even a cursory examination of the facts calls into the question the validity of using AIT as a primary screening mechanism. In weighing the competing interests above, the D.C. Circuit simply concluded, “That balance clearly favors the government here,” and proceeded to argue that AIT can detect items that magnetometers cannot as well as that a passenger may choose to opt-out.

The Court failed to address two key concerns set forth by privacy advocates. First, the Court assumed that AIT provides a more effective search of the passenger. In a hearing before Congress on March 17, 2010, Steve Lord, Director of Homeland Security issues for the Government Accountability Office, voiced caution over the TSA’s decision to ramp up AIT orders as well as to make such screening primary rather than secondary. He cautioned that AIT technology has not received the rigorous testing and evaluation necessary to conclusively determine its effectiveness. Most startlingly, a GAO investigation revealed that the explosive device taped on to the 2009 Christmas Day bomber’s underpants might not even have been detectable by AIT.

In operation, AIT has failed at key junctures to detect the very threats it is supposed to protect against. Recently, a government agent successfully smuggled in a handgun in her bra on five different occasions during an undercover test at Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport. Each time she went through security, she was screened by AIT and each time the machine did not detect the weapon.

While a 100% failure rate is typically enough to halt any program, the TSA responded by reaffirming their commitment to procure more of these machines.

The court also failed to address what happens to passengers who are uncomfortable with full body scanners, except to say they can opt-out. While it is true that passengers can opt-out, when they do they are subjected to a degrading pat-down that a reasonable person could only label as groping. A Hobson’s choice of a government agent feeling every crack and crevice of your body or a machine disrobing you simply because you wish to travel is hardly a choice at all and still has not been justified beyond a vague goal of protecting against terrorism. 

Congress should respond to this court decision by restricting the use of full body scanners to secondary screening only. Fourth Amendment concerns coupled with the poor record of this technology are cause for grave concern. At the very least, Congress should restrict the use of these devices until the TSA solicits the requisite public input and pays more than lip service to concerns over the privacy and effectiveness of these machines.

Previous Article Woman Arrested for Groping TSA Agent
Next Article Review: The Westin Chosun, Seoul

About Author

Matthew Klint

Matthew is an avid traveler who calls Los Angeles home. Each year he travels more than 200,000 miles by air and has visited more than 135 countries. Working both in the aviation industry and as a travel consultant, Matthew has been featured in major media outlets around the world and uses his Live and Let's Fly blog to share the latest news in the airline industry, commentary on frequent flyer programs, and detailed reports of his worldwide travel.

Related Posts

  • United Airlines Wants Flight Attendants To Create “Wow Factor” Onboard

    March 30, 2023
  • Atlantic Airways New York

    Atlantic Airways Announces New York Service From Faroe Islands

    March 29, 2023
  • Air France-KLM Business Class Seat Fees

    Air France-KLM Business Class Seat Assignment Fees: Unwelcome Yet Reasonable

    March 28, 2023

2 Comments

  1. Shuji Reply
    July 20, 2011 at 5:06 pm

    http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-07-20/tsa-to-end-person-specific-body-scan-images.html

  2. Matthew Reply
    July 21, 2011 at 11:22 pm

    I’ll have some thoughts on this over the weekend. I will say now that it is a step in the right direction and helps to pacify some of my Fourth Amendment concerns.

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Search

Recent Posts

  • Why Did United Premier Silver Get Upgrade Ahead Of Premier Platinum? March 31, 2023
  • Frontier Airlines Pilot Selfie
    Frontier Airlines Passengers Pranked By Pilot “Selfie” March 31, 2023
  • Review: Stephanie’s Boston Logan Airport (Priority Pass Restaurant) March 31, 2023
  • Faroe Islands Trip Report
    Introduction: A Journey To The Magical Faroe Islands On Star Alliance March 30, 2023

Categories

Popular Posts

  • Kayleigh Scott United Airlines
    The Tragic Death Of A United Airlines Flight Attendant March 21, 2023
  • Delta SkyMiles Schedule Change
    UPDATE: Delta Air Lines Strands Senior Citizens In Middle East After Absurd Schedule Change March 29, 2023
  • Southwest Airlines Wife Slap
    Enraged Husband Attacks Man On Southwest Airlines Flight After He Bumps Wife March 8, 2023
  • United Polaris Lounge LAX Review
    Review: United Airlines Polaris Lounge Los Angeles (LAX) March 24, 2023

Archives

March 2023
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  
« Feb    

As seen on:

live_and_lets_fly

The new United Polaris Lounge at Washington Dulles The new United Polaris Lounge at Washington Dulles is the most beautiful of all Polaris Lounges. Stay tuned for a detailed look and many more photos on the blog tomorrow. Well done @united.
@malaysiaairlines just announced it would retire i @malaysiaairlines just announced it would retire its A380 fleet. While not surprising, it is sad to see the growing list of carriers retiring this superjumbo jet. On Malaysia Airlines, I flew the #A380 once from Kuala Lumpur (KUL) to London (LHR) and had the entire first class cabin to myself (full review on the blog). It was a beautiful flight that I will always remember.
Welcome to @fly_bur @aveloair! I am so excited tha Welcome to @fly_bur @aveloair! I am so excited that a new carrier, Avelo, has launched, especially from an airport just 12 minutes from my home!
I greatly miss the @lufthansa #747-8 at @flylaxair I greatly miss the @lufthansa #747-8 at @flylaxairport. Hopefully this summer it will return.

.
.
.
.
#Lufthansa #FirstClass #747 #747-8 #StarAlliance #Miles #Points
I recently spent a weekend at the @ventanabigsur. I recently spent a weekend at the @ventanabigsur. This is not only a lovely, all-inclusive resort, but one of the best properties to use your @hyatt World of Hyatt points.
.
.
.
.
#Hyatt #BigSur #California #WorldofHyatt #CA-1 #Points #Hotels
In terms of a spacious first class product, the @E In terms of a spacious first class product, the @Emirates suite on a 777-300ER is hard to beat. My preference is Suite 2K.

.
.
.
.
#Emirates #777 #firstclass
Nearly five years ago, I took a “break” from I Nearly five years ago, I took a “break” from Instagram ahead of the birth of my first child. Goodness, how time flies. While I’ve enjoyed catching up on others over the years, now it is time for me to return to Instagram. In this first post, I highlight two joys in my life, my two children, whom I trust will grow up to be prolific travelers that circumnavigate the globe as ambassadors of love and respect.

.
.
.
.
.

#travel #airplanes #airlines #miles #points #familytravel #human #integrity #honor
United Airlines' new Polaris seat is a huge improv United Airlines' new Polaris seat is a huge improvement over UA's current business class seat. Check out my blog at liveandletsfly.com for 70+ photos of how @united is transforming its entire business class experience starting this December!
The perfect @flysas name tag for #Longyearben! The perfect @flysas name tag for #Longyearben!
Spotted four #polarbear outside of #longyearbyen - Spotted four #polarbear outside of #longyearbyen -- oh, and I love 40°F summer weather!
One of the best crews I have ever had the pleasure One of the best crews I have ever had the pleasure of flying with in all my years of flying. Thank you @flysas SK940 on 11 Aug 2016
Next stop ARN! But dear @flysas , next time if I a Next stop ARN! But dear @flysas , next time if I assign a window seat months in advance, don't move me to a center seat "for my convenience" with no way to get my original seat back... 😞
Ready for #PIA from #MAN to #JFK -- we will be rac Ready for #PIA from #MAN to #JFK -- we will be racing the #Delta flight to JFK at the gate next to us, which also departs at 12:45p. With @onemileatatime
Another room with a beautiful view... #hyattregenc Another room with a beautiful view... #hyattregencycasablanca #cassablanca #hyatt
Enjoying #shanghai with @onemileatatime from the i Enjoying #shanghai with @onemileatatime from the inside of the @grandhyatt_shanghai ... It is 40°C outside! 😓
From my front gate to my boarding gate in 15 minut From my front gate to my boarding gate in 15 minutes flat. I ❤️ #bur #burbankairport
@malaysiaairlines #747 out of retirement and in se @malaysiaairlines #747 out of retirement and in service at #kul -- beautiful livery!
View from my 61st floor room at the beautiful bran View from my 61st floor room at the beautiful brand new @parkhyattguangzhou -- look for a full review coming soon on the blog #hyatt #parkhyatt #guangzhou #parkhyattguangzhou
Will miss the @united #globalfirstlounge at #ord, Will miss the @united #globalfirstlounge at #ord, which closes tomorrow and the Queen of the Skies #747 which will be retired in 2018.
The colonial #architecture of #mumbai is stunning. The colonial #architecture of #mumbai is stunning. If you're ever here, get up at 5am and have a walk around the city before it gets busy. You can hear the birds instead of honking horns.
Load More... Follow on Instagram
facebook twitter instagram rss

This site is for entertainment purposes only. The owner of this site is not an investment advisor, financial planner, nor legal or tax professional and articles here are of an opinion and general nature and should not be relied upon for individual circumstances.

 

Advertiser Disclosure: Some links to credit cards and other products on this website will earn an affiliate commission. Outside of banner ads published through the Boarding Area network, this compensation does not impact how and where products appear on this site. While we do try to list all the best miles and points deals, the site does not include all card companies or credit card offers available in the marketplace. Please view our advertising policy page for additional details about our partners.

 

Editorial Disclosure: The editorial content on this page is not provided by any entity mentioned herein. Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.