A pair of black passengers claim they were racially profiled aboard a British Airways flight after a flight attendant questioned whether they were supposed to be sitting in their assigned seats. I understand why the interaction felt uncomfortable, but the video offers very little evidence that race had anything to do with it.
British Airways Passenger Claims Racial Profiling After Flight Attendant Questions His Seat. I’m Not Convinced.
A video circulating on social media accuses British Airways of racial profiling after a flight attendant approached two passengers shortly after they sat down aboard a flight from New York (JFK) to London Heathrow (LHR).
View this post on Instagram
The brothers were traveling onward to Lisbon and eventually Cabo Verde. According to their account, a flight attendant came over and questioned whether they were supposed to be seated there. One of the men interpreted the interaction as evidence that the crew member assumed two black passengers did not belong in those seats.
Perhaps there is more to the story than what appears in the brief video. But based on what is shown, I am not persuaded this was racial profiling.
The Exact Same Thing Just Happened To Me On Lufthansa
On a recent Lufthansa flight, a flight attendant approached me after boarding and questioned my presence in the cabin.
Was it because I am white?
Of course not.
For reasons no one could immediately explain, I did not appear on the flight attendant’s iPad. I had a valid boarding pass, had boarded normally, and was sitting in my assigned seat, but the onboard passenger information did not match the tablet.
The flight attendant checked my boarding pass, confirmed that I belonged there, and moved on.
It was mildly awkward, but it was also obvious what had happened: a technical discrepancy.
Passenger information does not always synchronize perfectly between reservations systems, gate computers, last-minute seat changes, upgrades, and the devices used by cabin crews. A flight attendant who sees an occupied seat that appears empty on the manifest is expected to investigate…it is part of the job. It’s not harassment!
An Uncomfortable Question Is Not Necessarily Discrimination
None of this means racial profiling never occurs on airplanes.
It does, and airlines should take credible allegations seriously. A passenger who is repeatedly challenged while similarly situated travelers are left alone may have good reason to question whether bias played a role.
But an accusation as serious as racism requires more than the fact that a black passenger was questioned.
What exactly appeared on the flight attendant’s device?
Was there a last-minute seat assignment or ticketing issue?
Did the seats show as unoccupied?
Were the passengers sitting in the correct cabin and assigned seats?
Did the flight attendant explain why she approached them?
The video does not answer those questions.
Instead, it jumps from an uncomfortable interaction to the conclusion that the interaction must have been motivated by race.
That is not enough.
British Airways Should Still Handle These Situations Carefully
There is a right and wrong way to resolve a manifest discrepancy.
A flight attendant can politely say:
“I’m sorry to bother you, but these seats are not appearing as occupied on my device. May I quickly verify your boarding passes?”
That explains the concern without making passengers feel as though they are being accused of sneaking into a premium cabin.
If the British Airways crew member was abrupt, condescending, or failed to explain the reason for the inquiry, the passengers have every right to complain about the manner in which the situation was handled.
Good communication matters.
But poor communication is not automatically racial discrimination and listening to the exchange, it seems the British Airways cabin crew member was very nice here and even turned his iPad to show the seats were showing unassigned.
CONCLUSION
Two passengers say they were racially profiled after a British Airways flight attendant questioned whether they belonged in their seats aboard a flight from New York to London.
I understand why that could feel embarrassing, particularly if the inquiry was handled without tact.
But the same thing recently happened to me on Lufthansa, and the explanation was entirely mundane: I simply did not appear on the flight attendant’s iPad.
Flight attendants have plenty to do during boarding. It seems far more likely that the crew member was resolving a passenger-manifest discrepancy than randomly deciding to challenge two travelers because of their race.
Could bias have played a role? Perhaps. But this video does not prove it. I’m not convinced.
Not to be ‘that guy,’ but… in his Instagram post, he captions that he’s in First Class, when that’s clearly British Airways Club World, their long-haul *business* class cabin. Ya know, an av-geek ‘umm ackchuallee’ because BA does have F.
I just think he’s absolutely full of it. Listen to how apologetic the BA FA is…
Not to mention, a truly great airline/crew will have flight attendants and the purser introduce themselves during boarding, individually, to each business class, and especially first class, passenger, verifying names, discussing pre-departure beverage and on-board meal preferences, pajama sizes, distributing amenity kits, etc. So, perhaps, this is an inexperienced traveler moment, like, him not realizing that a good crew does that, and mistaking it as ‘profiling’; or, it’s just content-farming. Either way, hope the poster enjoyed their premium cabin experience, regardless. No matter who you are, no matter the route, etc., it’s still usually ‘quite nice’ to be up-front.
It sure sounds like it was exactly what happened to you on Lufthansa. He is so bothered the FA asked for a boarding pass not name. But, that just supports the assertion that, for whatever reason, the seats were showing empty. I have to guess that when I sit in 3A and 3A is assigned to a pax, then the FA assumes I’m that pax. No need to check, if someone shows up claiming to be in 3A, then boarding passes are requested. If you know F is full, you needn’t do anything. If you know F is full except 4A and 4B, then approach anybody who sits in those two seats.
Some people go through life thinking every negative interaction is because of race, for many it pays off playing the victim always
Maybe it was less an issue of race, and more of an issue of fashion……wearing a sleeveless shirt looking like you just came out of the gym, a weave full of dreadlocks, and what looks to be a ball of pubes glued to the bottom of your chin…..not what I would envision as the typical BA passenger but what do i know
He does look silly, yes.
If you don’t understand that this is racism, then you are part of the problem Matthew. Next time try checking your white privilege before writing this kind of hit piece shaming the victims.
I agree with you. I imagine that many of the comments are being made by white males.
You should do some work to remove the gargantuan chip on your own shoulder, and disabuse yourself of the ridiculous notion that it’s still 1930, and every interaction between a non-white person and a white person is indelibly tainted by heinous, Jim Crow bigotry. Overreacting in this manner does not serve your cause; rather, you cast yourself as juvenile, unsophisticated reactionary with, as I said, a gargantuan chip on their shoulder.
Can it, Janet. Next try checking your out of control snowflake trigger and setting it to zero. And shut up about white privilege. You know more privilege in your hourly rants than anybody. You’re an attention seeking emotionally stunted hamster.
Very good job. People didn’t notice you just posted a standard, stupid comment to get them reacting. The “checking your white privilege” addition is classic. Thanks for the chuckle.
Sad to go through life looking for “Micro Agressions” and playing the race card. Get over it. Black people specifically seem to do this more than others. Trust me it often isn’t about your race.
The fatigue is real.
Sometimes appearance says it all. The worst crime ridden neighborhoods have thousands of people who look like this guy……. and He looks like a guy who looks like a girl trying to look like a guy…… and try shaving that mess of hair on your neck and stop looking like you’re in the hood. Then, just maybe, you’ll look presentable and civilized and not looked be looked at askance or questioning ??
Oh but it’s the kultcha you bigot!
Bigoted yourself if you’re segregating people by their “culture”.
People who present like the subject of the article claim it’s their “culture” to look like a low-level cannabis dealer at all times.
Black people lying about racism to get attention? I’m shocked.
I couldn’t make out everything that was being said to him. But, I think, he just would not accept it was a request having nothing to do with his race (and most likely from a disconnect between the FA’s tablet and the reservation system). But, of course, he could be a guy that figures posting this might make the airline give him something.
BTW, returning to Matthews’s point, assuming it was because the FA’s tablet didn’t show them in the seat, the FA should has said exactly what Matthew suggested. Nip it in the bud.
Easy explanation. The FA doesn’t speak jive.